Recent Posts
When it comes to industrial uses, choosing between brass and bronze bushings is very important for getting the best performance, longest life, and lowest cost. Both are copper-based alloys, but they have different qualities that make them better for different situations. This article goes over the main differences, benefits, and uses of each option to help you make a smart choice.
Table of Contents
1. Structure and Important Features
Brass Bushings: Mostly copper and zinc, but some grades may have lead or tin added.
Hardness: It is softer than bronze and has a Brinell hardness (HB) of 70 to 90.
Strength: Moderate tensile strength (360–500 MPa), good for light to medium loads.
Machinability: Great, which means that it can be used to make complicated shapes quickly.
Corrosion Resistance: Works well in mild settings, although saltwater might cause dezincification.
Copper mixed with tin, aluminium, or phosphorous makes up the material. Some common variations are:
SAE 660 (C93200): Bearings that don’t wear out easily.
Aluminium Bronze (like CuAl10Fe5Ni5) is very strong and resistant to rust.
Hardness: More difficult than brass (HB 60–190, depending on the alloy).
Strength: The tensile strength is between 240 and 700 MPa, and it can hold more weight than other materials.
Self-Lubricating Options: Sintered bronze that is clogged with graphite or soaked in oil so that it doesn’t need to be maintained.
2. Performance Comparison
| Criteria | Brass Bushings | Bronze Bushings |
|---|---|---|
| Load Capacity | Moderate (≤30 MPa) | High (50–98 MPa) |
| Wear Resistance | Fair; prone to deformation under heavy load | Excellent; ideal for high-friction environments |
| Corrosion Resistance | Good in dry/mild environments | Superior in marine/chemical settings |
| Temperature Tolerance | Up to 900°C (self-lubricating types) | High thermal conductivity; stable under heat |
| Cost | Lower initial cost | Higher due to tin/alloying elements |
3. Suggestions Based on Use
Brass bushings are best for low to moderate loads, including those found in cars, household appliances, and low-speed machines.
Cost-Sensitive Projects: Making a lot of anything where machinability lowers labour costs.
Non-Maritime Corrosive Environments: Plumbing fixtures and electrical parts.
Heavy-Duty Uses: Bronze bushings are best for landing gear bushings in aircraft, hydraulic presses, and rolling mill spindles.
High-Temperature or High-Friction Self-lubricating bronze works best in places where lubrication is hard to get to or where things move back and forth.
Harsh environments include marine hardware, chemical processes, and mining equipment.
4. New Technologies for Self-lubrication
Graphite-Plugged Bronze: Graphite inserts keep things lubricated all the time, which cuts down on friction and wear even when the pressure is quite high.
Oil-Impregnated Sintered Bronze: The porosity holds 18–25% oil by volume, making it perfect for activities that don’t need maintenance.
Composite Bushings: Blends of bronze and graphite can handle PV values up to 180,000 psi·fpm.
5. Cost vs. Lifecycle Analysis
Brass bushings are cheaper to buy at first, but bronze usually has a superior total cost of ownership (TCO) because:
Less time spent on repairs and downtime.
Lasts longer in tough situations.
Recovering scrap value (for example, bronze scrap keeps up to 90% of its value).
6. Conclusion: Choosing the Right Thing
Choose brass if you want to save money, make things easier to work with, and have average performance in places that don’t corrode.
Choose bronze if you need to lift large things, work in harsh conditions, or don’t want to have to lubricate it yourself. Its long life reduces downtime and lifecycle costs.
Need a solution just for you?
Our engineering staff is great at making bushings that fit your needs. Get in touch with us for a free estimate and technical advice.
7. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Which is better for use in saltwater, brass or bronze?
A: Bronze bushings, especially aluminium bronze, are better at resisting corrosion in marine settings. Brass can lose its zinc in saltwater.
Q2: Are self-lubricating bronze bushings strong enough to sustain heavy loads?
A: Yes. Bronze with graphite plugs can hold heavy weights and move slowly, which makes it good for excavator pivots and turbine blade trunnions.
Q3: Does brass wear out pivots more quickly than bronze?
A: Not always. The wear on a pivot depends on how smooth the surface is, how well it is lubricated, and how well it is aligned. Well-burnished pivots can last a long time with either type of material.
Q4: When should I not use bushings that have oil in them?
A: Don’t use them in places where cleanliness is very important (like food processing), because oil leaks can cause contamination.
Q5: Is it worth it to pay more for bronze bushings?
A: Yes, if the application has a lot of weight, heat, or corrosion. The investment is worth it because the product lasts longer and needs less upkeep.
100000+ Types of Bushings – Contact Us for Details